Notes

Tidewing X gets smaller

The Pacific boat went from 4.7 m and 169 kg to 2.6 m and 102 kg once I put the requirements back in the right order.

For several rounds, the Tidewing X sizing study kept producing a 4.7 m, 169 kg boat. That is far more than one person can launch from a ramp.

The cause was one number. Early on, the model got a 2.0 kt minimum speed with a hull fouled for six months, and that floor was quietly treated as a hard requirement. Every round, the optimiser grew the boat to meet it.

But speed was never the point. The real priorities were:

  1. one person can handle it, launch and haul-out included;
  2. the smallest, cheapest boat with the least lead;
  3. it survives and gets home;
  4. speed is whatever comes out.

With the requirements in that order, the answer is a 2.6 m, 102 kg boat. It breaks into 17 pieces with one hex key and goes to the ramp in two hatchback trips. It makes 1.59 kt against the old floor, and that’s fine.

The lesson isn’t really about boats: write the priorities down in order, and check that the model obeys them.